The Morality of Manipulation Let’s admit it, we in the consumer web industry are in the manipulation business. We build products meant to persuade people to do what we want them to do. We call these people “users” and even if we don’t say it aloud, we secretly wish every one of them would become fiendishly addicted.Users take our technologies with them to bed. When they wake up, they check for notifications, tweets, and updates before saying “good morning” to their loved ones. Ian Bogost, the famed game creator and professor, calls the wave of habit-forming technologies the “cigarette of this century” and warns of equally addictive and potentially destructive side-effects.When Is Manipulation Wrong?Manipulation is a designed experience crafted to change behavior — we all know what it feels like. We’re uncomfortable when we sense someone is trying to make us do something we wouldn’t do otherwise, like when at a car dealership or a timeshare presentation.Yet, manipulation can’t be all bad. If it were, what explains the numerous multi-billion dollar industries that rely heavily on users willfully submitting to manipulation? If manipulation is a designed experience crafted to change behavior, then Weight Watchers, one of the most successful mass-manipulation products in history, fits the definition.Much like in the consumer web industry, Weight Watchers customers’ decisions are programed by the designer of the system. Yet few question the morality of Weight Watchers. But what’s the difference? Why is manipulating users through flashy advertising or addictive video games thought to be distasteful while a strict system of food rationing is considered laudable?A More Addictive WorldUnfortunately, our moral compass has not caught-up with what technology now makes possible. Ubiquitous access to the web, transferring greater amounts of personal data at faster speeds than ever before, has created a more addictive world. Addictiveness is accelerating and according to Paul Graham of Y Combinator, we haven’t had time to develop societal “antibodies to addictive new things.” Graham puts responsibility on the user: “Unless we want to be canaries in the coal mine of each new addiction — the people whose sad example becomes a lesson to future generations — we’ll have to figure out for ourselves what to avoid and how.”But what of the people who make these manipulative experiences? The corporations who unleash these addictive technologies are, after all, made up of human beings with a moral sense of right and wrong. We too have families and kids who are susceptible to addiction and manipulation. What shared responsibilities do we code slingers and behavior designers have to our users, to future generations, and to ourselves?The Manipulation MatrixI offer a simple decision support tool for entrepreneurs, employees, and investors to be used long before product is shipped or code is written; even before customer development has begun. The Manipulation Matrix does not try and answer which businesses are moral or which will succeed. Nor does it describe what can and cannot become a habit-forming technology. The matrix seeks to help you answer not, “Can I hook users?” but “Should I attempt to?”To use the Manipulation Matrix, the maker needs to ask two questions. First, “Will I use the product myself?” and second, “Will the product help users materially improve their lives?” The FacilitatorWhen you create something that you will use and believe makes the user’s life better, you’re facilitating a healthful habit. It’s important to note that only you can decide if you would actually use the service and what “materially improving the life of the user” really means.If you find yourself squirming as you ask yourself those questions or needing to create a preamble starting with, “If I were a…” STOP! You failed. You have to actually want to use the product and believe it materially benefits your life as well as the lives of your users. The one exception is if you would have been a user in your younger years. For example, in the case of an education company, you may not need to use the service right now, but are positive you would have used it in your not so distant past. Note however that the further you are from your former self, the lower your odds of success.While I don’t know Mark Zuckerberg or the Twitter founders personally, I believe from their well-documented stories that they would see themselves as making products in this quadrant. There is also a long list of companies creating new products to improve lives by facilitating healthful habits. Whether getting users to exercise more, creating a habit of journaling, or improving back posture, these companies are run by authentic entrepreneurs who desperately want their products to exist, firstly to satisfy their own needs.But what about when an addiction to a well-intended product becomes extreme, even harmful? For a product in this quadrant, I agree with Paul Graham in saying the responsibility falls to the user. In any normal distribution, a small percentage of people will be on the extremes. If the designers make a product that they would use themselves, and they believe it improves the lives of their users, they have fulfilled their moral obligation. To take liberties with Mahatma Gandhi, facilitators “build the change they want to see in the world.”The PeddlerBut heady altruistic ambitions can at times, get ahead of reality. Too often, designers of manipulative technology have a strong motivation to improve the lives of their users, but when pressed, they admit they would not actually use their own creations. Their holier-than-thou products often try to “gamify” some task no one actually wants to do by inserting hackneyed incentives like badges or points that don’t actually hold value for the user.Fitness apps, charity websites, and products that claim to suddenly turn hard work into fun often fall in this quadrant. But possibly the most common example is in peddler advertising. Countless companies convince themselves they’re making ad campaigns users will love. They expect their videos to go viral and their branded apps to be used daily. Their reality distortion fields keep them from asking the critical question of, “Would I actually find this useful?” The answer to this uncomfortable question is nearly always “No,” so they bend their brain into the mind of a user they believe might find the ad valuable.Materially improving users’ lives is a tall order. But attempting to create a persuasive technology which you don’t find valuable enough to use yourself is nearly impossible. There’s nothing immoral about peddling; it’s just the odds of success are depressingly low. You’ll lack the empathy and insights needed to create something users actually want. The peddler’s project tends to end up a time-wasting failure because fundamentally, no one finds it useful or fun. If it were, the peddler would be using it instead of hawking it.The EntertainerIn fact, sometimes makers just want to have fun. If a creator of a potentially addictive technology makes something that they would use but can’t in good conscience claim improves the lives of their users, they’re making entertainment.Entertainment is art and is important for its own sake. Art provides joy, helps us see the world differently, and connects us with the human condition. These are all important and age old pursuits. Entertainment, however, has particular attributes which the entrepreneur, employee, and investor should be aware of when using the Manipulation Matrix.Art is often fleeting; products that form addictions around entertainment tend to fade quickly from users’ lives. A hit song, repeated over and over again in the mind, becomes nostalgia after it is replaced by the next single. A blog article like this one is read, shared, and thought about for a few minutes until the next interesting piece of brain candy comes along. Games like Farmville and Angry Birds engross users for a while, but then are relegated to the gaming dustbin along other hyper-addictive has-beens like Pac Man and Tetris.Entertainment is a hits-driven business because the brain adapts to stimulus. Art is about creating continuous novelty and building an enterprise on ephemeral desires is a constantly running treadmill. In this quadrant, the sustainable business isn’t the game, the song, or the book — it’s the distribution system for getting those goods to market while they’re still hot.The DealerCreating a product that the designer does not believe improves the user’s life and which the maker would not use is exploitation. In the absence of these two criteria, presumably the only reason you’re hooking users is to make a buck. Certainly there is money to be made addicting users to behaviors that do little more than extract cash; and where there is cash, there will be someone willing to take it.The question is: Is that someone you? Casinos and drug dealers offer users a good time, but when the addiction takes hold, the fun stops.In a satirical take on Zynga’s Farmville franchise Ian Bogost created Cow Clicker, a Facebook app where users did nothing but incessantly click on virtual cows to hear a satisfying “moo.” Bogost intended to lampoon Farmville by blatantly implementing the same game mechanics and viral hacks he thought would be laughably obvious to users. But after the app’s usage exploded and some people became frighteningly obsessed with the game, Bogost shut it down, bringing on what he called, “The Cowpocalypse.”Judging for YourselfBogost was right in comparing addictive technology to the cigarette. Certainly, the incessant need for a smoke in what was once the majority of the adult population has been replaced by a nearly equal compulsion to constantly check our devices. But unlike the addiction to nicotine, new technologies offer an opportunity to dramatically improve the lives of users. It’s clear that like all technologies, recent advances in the habit-forming potential of web innovation have both positive and negative effects.But if the innovator has a clear conscience that the product materially improves people’s lives — first among them, the creator’s — then the only path is to push forward. Users bear ultimate responsibility for their actions and makers should not be blamed for the misuse or overuse of their products.However, as the march of technology makes the world a more addictive place, innovators need to consider their role. It will be years, perhaps generations, before society develops the antibodies to new addictions. In the meantime, users will have to judge the yet unknown consequences for themselves, while creators will have to live with the moral repercussions of how they spend their professional lives.My hope is that Manipulation Matrix helps innovators consider the implications of the products they create. Perhaps after reading this, you’ll start a new business. Maybe you’ll join an existing company with a mission you believe in. Or, perhaps after reading this you’ll decide it’s time to quit your job, which you now come to realize no longer agrees with your moral compass.Thank you to Amy Jo Kim, Jess Bachman, Max Ogles for reading early versions of this essay.Photo Credit: byJess.net and Sarah G…If you found this post interesting, it would mean a lot to me if you could click on the “claps” icon below to let me know. That would really make my day — thanks!Nir Eyal is the author of Hooked: How to Build Habit-Forming Products and blogs about the psychology of products at NirAndFar.com.For more insights on changing behavior, join his free newsletter and receive a free workbook.
Ir a la fuente / Author: Nir Eyal

Apuesta por el SEO: seox@seox.es  /  656 545 123 Tú me VES, Yo NO TE VEO... ¿CUANTO ME CUESTA HACER SEO EN MI PÁGINA WEB? seo onpage / seo offpage
SeoX RSS Aviso SeoX/   /   SeoX.es - seox@seox.es https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.es_ES
[quads id=2][quads id=3][quads id=4]seo marketing online seo marketing definicion seo marketing wikipedia seo marketing peru seo marketing definition seo marketing digital pdf seo marketing companies seo marketing strategies seo marketing strategy seo marketing tips seo marketing adalah seo marketing articles seo marketing australia seo marketing analyst seo marketing assistant seo marketing agencia seo marketing agentur seo marketing agency seo marketing amazon internet marketing seo intro what is a seo marketing campaign seo a content marketing what is a seo marketing how to start a seo marketing company seo marketing books seo marketing blogs seo marketing basics seo marketing benefits seo marketing business seo marketing berlin seo marketing brasil seo marketing bedeutung seo marketing brisbane seo marketing breda seo marketing courses seo marketing cost seo marketing companies in india seo marketing campaign seo marketing classes seo marketing channel seo marketing calgary seo marketing conference seo marketing career seo content marketingg seo marketing deutsch seo marketing definitie seo marketing dubai seo marketing degree seo marketing définition seo marketing dallas definicion de seo marketing seo de marketing seo marketing examples seo marketing executive seo marketing explained seo marketing executive job description seo marketing español seo marketing experts seo marketing english seo email marketing example seo marketing edmonton seo marketing education seo optimizacion e internet marketing seo en marketing seo sem en-marketing seo e inbound marketing email marketing seo digital marketing seo seo e marketing strategies seo e web marketing 360 e marketing seo seo e content marketing seo marketing for dummies seo marketing for beginners seo marketing funnel seo marketing forum seo marketing facebook seo marketing facts seo marketing firm seo marketing for small business seo marketing for dentists seo marketing free seo marketing google seo marketing guide seo marketing glasgow seo marketing gold coast seo marketing graph seo-küche internet marketing gmbh godaddy seo marketing seo-guerilla marketing seo marketing là gì seo-küche internet marketing gmbh & co. kg seo marketing how to seo marketing hannover seo marketing houston seo marketing help seo marketing hong kong seo marketing hashtags seo marketing houston texas marketing holistico seo affiliate marketing seo hack to boost your affiliate sales smart seo seo marketing html theme seo marketing india seo marketing interview questions seo marketing internship seo marketing images seo marketing infographic seo marketing intern seo marketing i mes seo marketing icons internet marketing seo intro project for after effects seo i content marketing seo marketing jobs seo marketing job description seo marketing jelentése seo marketing jobs london seo marketing job salary seo marketing jobs manchester seo digital marketing jobs seo marketing manager job description seo marketing strategist job description seo marketing keywords seo marketing kansas city seo marketing köln seo marketing kosten seo marketing kurs seo marketing kenya seo marketing que es seo keyword marketing keystone seo marketing seo marketing las vegas seo marketing london seo marketing land seo marketing logo seo marketing long island seo marketing los angeles seo marketing leeds seo marketing meaning seo marketing manager seo marketing manager salary seo marketing miami seo marketing means seo marketing manchester seo marketing mix seo marketing melbourne seo marketing malaysia seo marketing near me seo marketing news seo marketing nyc seo marketing new york seo marketing nedir seo marketing ninjas seo marketing nederland seo marketing newsletter seo marketing online course seo marketing online services seo marketing on google seo marketing online classes seo marketing orange county seo marketing objectives curso seo marketing online seo y marketing digital seo y marketing de contenidos seo marketing plan seo marketing prices seo marketing plan template seo marketing plan ppt seo marketing plan sample seo marketing plan example seo marketing philippines seo marketing podcast seo marketing packages seo marketing quotes seo digital marketing interview questions marketing qua seo que es seo marketing que es seo marketing online que es seo marketing digital seo marketing resume seo marketing raleigh seo marketing reddit seo marketing resume sample seo marketing rpmg online technology seo marketing report seo marketing reviews seorank marketing services seo marketing salary seo marketing specialist seo marketing san diego seo marketing service inc seo marketing specialist salary seo marketing strategy 2017 seo marketing strategy 2018 seo marketing statistics seo marketing social media seo marketing skills seo marketing sl seo marketing tools seo marketing services seo marketing techniques seo marketing term seo marketing tutorial seo marketing toronto seo marketing training seo marketing tactics seo marketing template seo marketing trends seo marketing tips 2017 seo marketing uk seo marketing usa seo marketing utah seo marketing unlimited seo marketing companies usa seo marketing companies uk seo marketing manager salary uk understanding seo marketing united seo marketing seo marketing vancouver seo marketing vector seo marketing ventajas seo marketing video seo marketing video tutorials seo marketing online valencia marketing virtual seo seo viral marketing internet marketing vs seo v internet-marketing-seo-intro.rar sem vs seo marketing seo vs internet marketing seo marketing wiki seo marketing what is it seo marketing wordpress theme seo marketing web seo marketing websites seo marketing workshop seo marketing writing seo marketing weiterbildung seo marketing wien seo marketingh seo marketing youtube marketing seo y sem yo seo marketing sem y seo marketing seo y sem marketing online seo y sem marketing digital seo and marketing services seo and marketing tools cpanel seo and marketing tools seo marketing coordinator zillow seo marketing error 404 error404 seo 404 seo 301 seo redirect 301 redirect 301 seo redirect301 seo301 seoo 301 seo marketing seo marketing 2025 seo marketing 2024 seo marketing 2023 seo marketing 2022 seo marketing 2021 seo marketing 2020 seo marketing 2019 seo marketing 2018 seo marketing 20188 seo marketing 2017 seo marketing 20177 seo marketing 2016 seo marketing 2015 seo marketing 2014 seo marketing strategies 2016 seo content marketing 2015 seo marketing strategies 2015 seo marketing tips 2014 seo marketing tips 2015 seo affiliate marketing 2016 smart seo-v1-2-seo-marketing-services seo for marketing seo marketing for real estate seo marketing for law firms seo marketing for lawyers seo marketing for restaurants seo marketing for hotels

Related Post

Otros artículos relacionados: